The Philippines recently saw the introduction of the "Bagong Pilipinas" (New Philippines) hymn, intended to be sung during flag ceremonies in schools and government offices. However, the song has been met with criticism, raising questions about its effectiveness and its underlying message.
Music Critics Doubt the Melody
Musicians and artists have voiced concerns about the hymn's artistic merit. Edgie Francis Uyanguren, from the Concerned Artists of the Philippines, called the melody "awful" and the lyrics "forgettable." He believes the song wouldn't even make it past the initial stages of a songwriting competition. Mony Romana, a music professor, finds the song "too long" and lacking the emotional depth needed to inspire. He argues that a hymn should evoke feelings of patriotism and love for the country, something the "Bagong Pilipinas" hymn fails to achieve in his opinion.
"Pop Song" vs. National Hymn?
Another criticism centers on the song's style. Romana compares it to a pop song, unsuitable for the solemn atmosphere of a flag ceremony. Choi Padilla, a music producer, goes further, calling it a "campaign tune" rather than a national hymn. He feels the focus on "Bagong Pilipinas" suggests an agenda and lacks the unifying power a national anthem should possess.
Beyond the Music: Historical Parallels and Questions
The timing of the hymn's introduction raises eyebrows for some. The Marcos administration, known for its association with the martial law era, mandated the song. Parallels are being drawn between the "Bagong Pilipinas" and the upbeat "Bagong Lipunan" (New Society) anthem used during the Marcos Sr. regime. Critics see this as an attempt to rewrite history and whitewash the memories of a dark period in Philippine history.
What's Next for "Bagong Pilipinas"?
The "Bagong Pilipinas" hymn remains a source of debate. While the Marcos administration sees it as a symbol of a new era, critics question its artistic merit, underlying message, and historical context. Whether the song will become a unifying anthem or fade into obscurity remains to be seen.